Short answer: To compare builder quotes fairly, give every builder the same measured plan and specification, then compare the quotes line by line for scope, provisional sums, VAT, exclusions, programme and payment schedule. A cheaper total often leaves out something the dearer one includes.
Give every builder the same brief
Quotes only compare when the scope is identical. Provide a measured plan, photos, a finishes schedule and a list of what you are supplying. A room built in 3D from your own photos, and shared as a link, gives each builder the same picture without a site visit for the first pass.
What to check line by line
| Item | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Scope | Same rooms, same finishes, same structural work |
| Provisional sums | How much is allowed for tiles, sanitaryware, kitchen and electrics |
| Exclusions | Skips, scaffolding, making good, decoration, fees |
| VAT | Included or not, and the rate |
| Programme | Start date, duration and what slips if the weather or deliveries do |
| Payment | Stage payments tied to work done, not dates |
Red flags
- A large deposit before any work or materials are on site.
- No written scope, only a total.
- Prices far below the others with no explanation.
- No insurance details or unwillingness to share references.
After you choose
Sign a written contract, keep a variations log and hold back a retention until snagging is complete. Our guide on checking a builder before paying a deposit covers insurance and references.
Frequently asked questions
How many quotes should I get?
Three is the common minimum for a major project, but two or three with the same scope is better than five with different ones.
Should I pick the cheapest?
Not automatically. Compare what is included and how well the builder communicates before you decide.
Related guides
This guide is general information for homes in the UK, not legal, structural or financial advice. Costs are indicative ranges and vary with your property, region, specification and builder; always obtain written quotes.